More than 50 years have passed since i first encountered muslims. Nov 08, 2017 more than 50 years have passed since i first encountered muslims. With the help of god, we begin writing a debate that happened between the monk georgi and three moslem theologians, in the presence of the prince al khana, al. Muslim and christian debates 1 who corrupted the bible. In a muslim kingdom, citizens are allowed to enjoy both private and public rights. Many are sent to islamic schools, which continue the process day in, day out, often colouring every lesson with some link tenuous or otherwise to the koran, or mohammeds life. Hubert humphrey it is better to debate a question without settling it than to settle a question without debating it. For this answer ill be using the islamic sources to make my points. The christianmuslim debate was held last night at scsu atwood center voyager room with mr. Or perhaps i should start by citing the norwegian police. A christianmoslem debate of the 12th century internet history. A muslim is a person who surrenders, submits and obeys the laws of god.
Among the private rights, the most important is the right to safety which according to islamic law is guaranteed to. Four muslimchristian encounters in late antiquity uio duo. You are having a beautiful stroll through the park, when suddenly, you recognize your colleague from school andrew boutros. The social attraction of islam and a christian response debate. The muslim debates debate on multiculturalism multiculturalism in the west has reached its limits. Security services recent concern about mounting radicalization among muslim youth in norway, an issue. The spirit of islam christianity vs islam jay smith. Im not sure what the strongest argument against islam can be but i know of at least one moral argument against islam. Many real ones were held, and also imaginary ones produced, past and present. Early christianmuslim debate on the unity of god three christian. By continuing, we will assume you agree with our cookie policy. Islam and christianmuslim relations in norway the university of.
Alas, it was a warm debate among friends, and in some cases, family. Among the private rights, the most important is the right to safety which according to islamic law is guaranteed to all inhabitants irrespective of race and religion. As usual, nobody had any concrete evidence with which to support their side, so they ended up yelling and damning each other to hell. Jesus is the clue to the power and the wisdom of god, the. The muslim debate is an online debate forum to address challenges faced by muslims, through engaging intellectuals, scholars, academics, analysts, and professionals. In doing so it identifies the debates behind the debates. When islam and christianity clash, and when they dont the. Where one can get knowledge about islam and other religions.
Islam is a religion of peace all debates debate iq2us. Islam vs christianity debate popular christian videos. Above is a debate between edip yuksel and jay smith, uploaded by pfanderfilms in 2016. Oct 21, 2012 the christian muslim debate was held last night at scsu atwood center voyager room with mr. Two christian theologians writing in arabic in the early ninth century argued that god had created humanity to freely choose good or evil. The major sources are all available in english, and are the koran, the sira or the life of muhammad by ibn ishaq, and the hadith, the sayings and deeds of the prophet and his companions. Human rights and religion the islamic headscarf debate in. Your best rational arguments against islam with evidence, and 33 of my own. A messianic jew and former muslim on the allah vs god debate. The spirit of islam is a comprehensive study of islam, mohammad, the quran, hadith, sunah, and the khalafah.
Angel gabriel who foretold the birth of son of god is the real angel of true god and not jibril, the apocryphal false angel, who supposedly claimed he is an angel messenger of god, he jibril who was witnessed by only one person muhammad who wage wars and did not perform any humanistic miracles, which unlike sinless jesus who was witnessed by many and brought. For more debates go to the engaging with islam youtube channel. Christian defence of free will in debate with muslims in the early. Muslim by choice has released a hilarious 10 clip countdown of the best muslim vs christian debates. Further dialogues were held between vatican theologians and saudi arabian muslim scholars in rome in 1970, 1974, and 1978. Corruption of the quran david wood and sam shamoun on abn. Apr 09, 2010 christians, if you were in a debate situation with a muslim, discussing the validity of each others faiths, what would your argument be. Religion is a place to discuss and debate religions, god, morality, spiritualism, and philosophy.
With the help of god, we begin writing a debate that happened between the monk georgi and three moslem theologians, in the presence of the prince alkhana, al. Im john donvan of abc news, and once again it is my honor to act as moderator as the four debaters you see sharing this stage with me here at the skirball center for the performing arts at new york university four debaters, two against two, will be debating this motion. Christians and muslims have been involved in exchanges over matters of faith and morality since the founding of islam. The debate was hosted by isra, islamic sciences and research academy australia. Abstract the archbishop of canterburys recent suggestion that sharia councils be formalised within the british legal system received strong criticism on the basis that such an institution would oppress muslim women. Through close examination of their writings on the doctrine of the trinity, sara husseini demonstrates the creativity of these theologians, who. Quran hadith my parents are forcing me to see a sheikh in a couple days to talk about my rational doubts with islam and why theyre irrational. Larycia hawkins, the political science professor who was suspended from wheaton college after saying christians and. Imran on the topic which is the word of god as you challenged in. If there is any christian who feels he is convinced that christianity is true and that the fundamental beliefs of christianity, such as the trinity, the incarnation, etc. We use cookies to give you the best user experience. Joseph joubert for in the absence of debate unrestricted utterance leads to the degradation of opinion. Labib mikhail who has authored over 60 books about the subject. Muslim n christian debate, greenville, mississippi.
While islam gives people the impression that they can change their lives by changing the way they act, or by becoming disciplined, or by simply adopting new names, it fails to pinpoint the essential criteria for a sincere lifechange. But the failure of muslim societies in particular the leaders to embrace education, expand economies or to innovate cannot be attributed solely to outside factors. Ahmed deedat who was comparative religion expert had clarified all the doubts and falsehoods regarding christianity. Many more discussions were held in colombo, not to mention muslims being invited by many churches to present islam in different parts of the world to their. Angel gabriel who foretold the birth of son of god is the real angel of true god and not jibril, the apocryphal false angel, who supposedly claimed he is an angel messenger of god, he jibril who was witnessed by only one person muhammad who wage wars and did not perform any humanistic miracles, which unlike sinless jesus who was witnessed by many and brought messages directly from god to.
The muslim debate s debate on multiculturalism multiculturalism in the west has reached its limits. I was teaching english at a catholic school in akure, a provincial capital in southwestern nigeria, when one of the muslim students at the school took me into town for one of the two great festivals of the muslim calendar. Isnt the weather lovely today, you remark, to which he replies, islam is a cult, the quran is violent, and muhammad was a warlord. I do disagree that i must make similar distinctions between judaism and the christian god as there is a clear path between the old testament and new. The truth of islam sam shamoun on abn who was muhammad muslim and christian debate is muhammad a good role model for society sami zaatari vs david wood. Abstract the archbishop of canterburys recent suggestion that sharia councils be formalised within the british legal system received strong criticism on the basis that.
Muslim christian debate channel is comparative religion information platform. Aug 08, 2016 the topic was social media causes more harm than benefit to the muslim community. This then brings us to the crux of the matter concerning the witness of islam and christianity in relation to the social agenda. How can christians committed to the classical christian tradition address the issues raised by contemporary islam. In each age, we seek ways to learn how to become more competent. When you do debate with a muslim make sure you are armed with all your references from the original arabic sources. Sami zataari and ustadh ali ataie, alongside infamous islamophobes, james white, jay smith and arsonist anis shorrosh. Entertaining and educational, its quite the video to watch. We discussed that in detail on rsikh and i recommend you read through that thread to see what the sangat on here had to say. Anis shorrosh in real audio failure of deedat to show up led to an impromptu debate with some other muslims. Supporters of the right to wear the islamic headscarf argue that the ban and similar prohibitions infringe a number of human rights. The root causes also lie in the fear of some muslims to embrace reasoned debate and intellectual exchange, lest this openness somehow dilute the purity of their beliefs. The topic was social media causes more harm than benefit to the muslim community.
Imrans lecture in 2006 and reverted to islam my name is omer now. This exchange is interesting in that we have one very liberal qurani muslim who rejects the entirety of the hadith, sira, tafsir, and 1400 years of quranic translation, versus one of the foremost authorities on islam and christian apologetics, jay smith. A messianic jew and former muslim on the allah vs god debate dr. Throughout the debates below, you will notice peoples names with next to them. With the help of god, we begin writing a debate that happened between the monk georgi and three moslem theologians, in the presence of the prince alkhana, almushar abulmulk, gazi alzaher usef ibn ayub alsalah, the moslem king of aleppo and syria, and during the reign of leo the armenian, son of etienne. Christians, if you were in a debate situation with a muslim, discussing the validity of each others faiths, what would your argument be. Often it seems that way between believers separated by their faiths. Muslim children tend to be indoctrinated toward, very hard, from a young age. The muslim debate initiative muslim debate news, commentary. Freedom is hammered out on the anvil of discussion, dissent, and debate.
The muslim must face that the quran says it confirms the prior scriptures yet presents those same scriptures in a false light. Detailed consideration is given to the headscarf debate in france. This book examines the issues by considering questions of language, meaning and symbolism. Nov 07, 2017 above is a debate between edip yuksel and jay smith, uploaded by pfanderfilms in 2016. Im going to try my hardest to answer your argument as best as i could by using my perspective mixed with some quran verses. I met the head of isra at an event for media held by the. Sharia councils and the oppression of muslim women jemma wilson. Now getting to your inquiry, bhai jagraj singh ji had a debate with another muslim at hyde park a while ago where the same issue was raised. December 28, 2014 admin authors, miscellaneous, rules of debate, saleh abdullah ibn humaid how to debate in islam, ibn humaid, principles of debate in islam, rules of debate in islam the main objectives of a debate are the substantiation of truth with proof and the refutation of doubts and fallacious statements and propositions. Matthew stone as a messianic jew, i have been following very carefully the controversy surrounding dr. Though we are all members of a community, forming a civil society is an arduous enterprise. Your best rational arguments against islam with evidence.
549 738 305 967 1521 894 619 44 1059 1085 1521 1047 901 1468 1269 1496 455 230 984 496 634 398 166 319 1003 32 660 332 566 4 316 880 1506 656 1436 485 279 625 1156 814 7 1436 527 36 1257